Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Three Stars from Raymond Chandler Films

Lauren Bacall "The Big Sleep" 1946.
I think I finally got Lauren Bacall in this drawing.  This is from early in the film, when she's sizing up Bogart's Phillip Marlowe.  She's got her own agenda that she's hiding from him, but she sees he might be able to help her.  I love her in this film.

Dick Powell "Murder, My Sweet" 1944
Powell's take on Marlowe is a little different than Bogart's.  He always seems a little bit more at the end of his rope, and he wears his bitterness on his sleeve.  He also gets beat up worse than Bogart, which I think is essential in films noir! 
Claire Trevor "Murder, My Sweet" 1944.
You couldn't cast a better Velma than Claire Trevor.  She's great at being a society lady with a secret past. 


Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Eight Leading Ladies


Claudette Colbert, "Skylark," 1941.
Claudette is funny in Skylark, a somewhat forgettable film from 1941.  She plays a woman thinking about leaving her workaholic, inattentive husband, played by Ray Milland, and flirts with the idea of having a fling with the lawyer handling her divorce, played by Brian Aherne.   But her husband makes an attempt to woo her back, promising to work less, and she stays with him, even though she had gone through with the divorce.  In the real world I picture the husband making the same mistakes and she eventually leaves him for good, but not in this saccharine story.


Catherine Deneuve, "Belle de Jour," 1967.
Luis Bunuel's surreal Belle du Jour is a puzzle to me.  I can't figure out if Deneuve, as the frigid housewife by night, prostitute in a high class brothel by day, is a repressed woman finding freedom in her alter ego, or just another objectified woman at the mercy of her misogynistic customers.  I guess that's Bunuel's point!
Faye Dunaway "Bonnie and Clyde" 1967.
I'm always impressed with the subtle way Dunaway, as Bonnie Parker, pushes Clyde to bigger and not-so-better things.  Bonnie is the one who wants the fame; Clyde seems to enjoy the thrill of living on the edge, and he likes his notoriety.  But Bonnie writes the poem that "tells their story."  She's the movie star.  Nowadays I imagine her finding her fame on a reality TV show.

Jane Fonda "Klute" 1971.
I had never seen thw detective film Klute before.  Fonda plays Bree, a neurotic prostitute at the center of a missing person case being investigated by Private Eye John Klute, played by Donald Sutherland.  Fonda won an Oscar for her performance, and she's pretty good at playing a call girl who seems to relish the seeming power she has over her clients, but underneath feels unfulfilled and lonely.
Some of her fellow prostitutes wind up murdered, and Fonda's bravado and strength seems to wither away as the danger gets closer and closer to her.  I think we are supposed to get the idea that Bree maybe isn't the personification of liberated feminism she pretends to be.  It's a fitting film for the ambivelent feelings people had towards Women's Liberation in the early 1970s.
Zsa Zsa Gabor, "Queen of Outer Space," 1958.
Zsa Zsa's performance is as stiff as a board in this schlocky '50s sci-fi picture made in the wake of "Forbidden Planet."  But the plot is interesting as an example of how "powerful" women were portrayed pre-Women's Lib.  A crew of male astronauts crash land on Venus.  They discover women control the planet, and there are no men.  (No old women or children, either, but for some reason that goes unexplained.)  The leader of the women wears a mask, although she seems quite lovely.  She's an authoritarian ruler, and it's discovered by the astronauts that she is in position of a death ray aimed at Earth to stop future aggression by men from that planet.  Zsa Zsa is the leader of a small resistance group intent on overthrowing their autocratic ruler.  She depends on the help of the men to overthrow the leader, whose face is revealed to be horribly disfigured from a previous war with men. 
I guess pretty girls can get the guys, but ugly girls are bitter and crazy!


Greer Garson "Random Harvest" 1942.
Random Harvest is one of my favorite romantic films.  Ronald Coleman plays a soldier with amnesia; he wanders out of the hospital in which he's being kept, and is nursed back to health by Greer Garson.  They marry, have a child, and create a life together.  He never remembers who he is.  Then one day on a business trip he gets hit by a car, and his memories come rushing back.  He's the scion of a wealthy family.  But he forgets his life with Garson!  He takes over the families' business interests.  She learns to forget him, until she applies for a job with his business.  She ends up his secretary!  He never remembers her, until he ends up in the town where he first met her, and his memories come rushing back.  It's a beautiful film.


Maureen O'Hara, "Do You Love Me," 1946.
Maureen plays a mousy music school dean who, upon meeting a charismatic band leader, takes off her glasses and becomes a glamorous gal, torn between the band leader and his lead singer.  It's a silly film, and Maureen is somewhat miscast.  But some of the musical numbers are fun.




Barbara Stanwyck, "There's Always Tomorrow," 1956.

My goodness, what a great, but depressing, film.  Fred MacMurray is a toy manufacturer, whose wife and three children take for granted.  Stanwyck is an old employee he once flirted with.  She looks him up when visiting town, and he thinks he might find with her what's lacking at home.  Stanwyck is interested in his work, and seems genuinely interested in his well being.  She pays him attention.  But she's a career gal, and has no interest in stealing him from his family, especially after she's confronted by MacMurray's teenaged son and daughter.  Ultimately she moves home, leaving Fred to his meddling, ungrateful children and a wife who still doesn't seem to care for him. 
I think Sirk pulls all the right melodramatic strings in this film.  MacMurray is truly put upon, although I wonder if he could be happy with his home life if he made more of an effort.  And I understand why Stanwyck bails.  MacMurray comes with too much baggage! 



Tuesday, August 12, 2014

Terribly Sad

Robin Williams, "The World According to Garp," 1982.

"You know, everybody dies.  My parents died, your father died, everybody dies.  I'm gonna die too.  So will you.  The thing is to have a life before we die.  It can be a real adventure, having a life." - Glenn Close as Jenny Fields, to the young TS (Terribly Sexy, Terribly Shy, Terribly Sad) Garp.  

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Two "Good" Germans

An entry in my continuing examination of the changing portrayal of Germans and German-Americans in Hollywood films during and after World War II.

The German Underground


Poldli Dur, “They Came to Blow Up America,” 1943.
     Poldi Dur, the screen name of Austrian born actress Elisabeth Reisch (nee Handl), has a small but interesting role in this B-film.  George Sanders stars as Carl Steelman, the German-American son of German immigrants living in Milwaukee.  Unbeknownst to his fiercely patriotic parents, loyal to America, their new country, Carl is working as an FBI spy investigating the German-American bund groups accused of supporting the Nazis.  The FBI sends Carl to Germany to impersonate a German named Ernst Reiter who is learning how to be an expert saboteur.

     Once in Germany Carl/Ernst meets Helga Lorenz, played by Dur, when she tries to buy stockings in a shop.  He uses his ration card to buy her the stockings.  After a few dates he discovers that she is working for the German underground, leaving anti-Nazi propaganda around the city.  One note reads “GERMANS!  The Nazis are plundering the Father-land to its doom!  Vast fortunes are deposited in Swiss and Italian banks by Nazi leaders!”

     He suggests that she stop her activities before she is caught, even hinting that her work isn’t significant enough to make the risk worthwhile.  Of course she refuses to quit.  Carl/Ernst is cautioned by his Gestapo colleagues to stop associating with known trouble-makers.  When she is eventually brought in for questioning, to her surprise he testifies against her.  

     But Carl/Ernst has a plan to free her.  He stops the car she is being transported in by blocking the road, then knocks out the two Nazi agents that had been guarding her.  He then gets back in his car and drives away with Helga, letting the Nazis chase them.  (Inexplicably he uses one of his bombs from saboteur class to blow up the Nazi’s car - it’s triggered to blow-up when it hits 70 MPH.  I wonder, wouldn’t the Nazis figure out that he blew up the car, as he is a known saboteur, and a known acquaintance of Helga’s??)

     Anyway, he gets her safely to a boat piloted by the German underground and she escapes.  He promises to see her again - but he never does!  This happens about halfway through the film, and Helga, with her interesting story of being a “good” German fighting the Nazis, at risk of her life, is left unexplored.  I was reminded of the terrible risks the Berlin protagonists of Hans Fallada’s Every Man Dies Alone take, as they leave notes decrying the Nazis around the city for people to discover.  They feel they must do something to fight the Nazis, and all the can do in protest is leave notes - which eventually gets them killed.  Helga’s plight is real - it would have been interesting to explore it in another kind of film.  I’m not sure Americans were aware of how terrible Nazi Germany was, even to it’s own German citizens, until well after the war.

     After Helga escapes. Carl/Ernst’s real wife appears, and tries to turn him in to the Gestapo as a spy, but Carl convinces the bumbling Gestapo head that she is mentally ill.  Eventually the Gestapo figures out they have been had.  It turns out that Carl’s dad, ill because of his son’s disloyalty to America, is told by the FBI that Carl is on a secret mission, and his father blabs to his friend, who is secretly an American Bund member loyal to the Nazis.  But by then Carl is on an U-Boat headed back to America, with the other newly minted saboteurs, with plans to “blow up America.”  Carl manages to keep his identity a secret, and he arrives in time to stop his fellow saboteurs and see his proud, loyal, German-American parents.

     So there are a number of “good” Germans in this film, including the folksy immigrant parents, Carl himself, as a first-generation American, and of course Helga, who has the most to risk in this film.  In a more realistic story she would not have escaped, and her resistance would have been in vain - but I think her insistence to carry on, despite Carl’s warnings, is interesting.  She is loyal to a country that is betraying her.  That takes courage.

     And it's also quite surprising for an American film, made during the war, to show any German with sympathy.  I think the filmmakers get away with it because the Helga character is so innocent.  There are also some comedic elements in this film (the oddest moment is when the Gestapo head throws darts at a photo of Winston Churchill), so this isn't a "serious" film.  Maybe that made it easier to show some elements of the enemy in a positive light.

     Poldi Dur had a brief career in Hollywood, mainly playing German accented supporting characters.  Her Austrian born husband was “Ninotchka” writer Walter Reisch, who also wrote “Gaslight,” “Comrade X,” and “Niagara.”   Surprising couple.

Sources:  Poldi Dur biography:  http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0243643/bio?ref_=nm_ov_bio_sm
Walter Reisch filmography: http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0281556/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1

Shared Guilt and the German Character

Marlon Brando, "The Young Lions," 1958.

     The Young Lions (1958) is an interesting film.  Directed by Edward Dmytryk, it reveals the experiences of three different soldiers in World War II.  Dean Martin is an entertainer, hesitant to join the war and face combat.  He’s loyal and patriotic, but he’s worried more about his own safety than the fate of his country.  Montgomery Clift is a soft-spoken Jewish kid, shy around women.  After he enlists he encounters prejudice from his fellow soldiers, and even his superiors, at boot camp.  He wants to defend America, at risk of his own life, but his fellow Americans stand in his way.  Both Martin and Clift have romantic interests that develop their characters.  Martin has a girlfriend who wants to marry him before he gets drafted, but he has cold feet.  She eventually helps encourage him to leave his soft assignment behind the lines and get sent to the front.  Clift falls in love with a girl who isn’t Jewish - but he gets accepted by her family and they marry. 

     Marlon Brando plays a German soldier who excels at his job.  He’s a good officer, and a good tactician.  But he’s ultimately not a “good” German, as far as his more ideological colleagues are concerned.  He meets and falls in love with a French girl, after the occupation of Paris.  Brando’s character has a friend who also falls for a French girl, and near the end of the war his friend deserts the German army to live with the girl.  His friend doesn’t understand why he’s fighting, and is basically apolitical.  He cares more about his own pleasure - and his own life - than any bigger ideas about country.  But his friend doesn’t see that this stance is actually political.  If anything his friend is a clueless existentialist.

     Brando, on the other hand, feels a duty to his country.  His idea of being a good German is following orders and doing his job.  He ends up as a subordinate to a cruel Captain played by Maximillian Schell.  Schell recognizes that being a “good” German during the war isn’t just following orders, but embracing the harsh ideology of Nazism.  Brando rejects Schell’s ideas, but he can’t see that staying in the war, even as something of an outsider, still makes him complicit in the Nazi’s crimes.

     It takes a visit to a death camp to change his mind.  Near the end of the war, separated from his unit, he wanders into a concentration camp looking for food.  At the camp he meets the camp commandant, who reveals to Brando that he’s got to get the executions moving before the Americans arrive.  Brando is sickened by the idea that he is eating bread while the camp inmates are starving to death and soon to be murdered; and he finally sees that this is what the Captain meant about being a good German. 

     There’s an interesting scene after the Americans - including Martin and Clift - liberate the camp.  The Jewish prisoners want to perform a religious service, but the local burgermeister and other officials are afraid it will get the local people worked up, and they want to deny the service - as if it’s the fault of the Jewish prisoners the local people will be offended.  The American Army officer in charge is appalled and throws the locals out.  I think this is shown to reinforce the idea not that Germans didn’t know about the camps, but that they continued to blame their victims for their fate, instead of seeing the problem was in themselves.

     Unfortunately Brando’s character is killed when he is caught by an American patrol (Clift and Martin, conveniently) in the woods near the camp.  Apparently the author of the original novel on which the film was based was displeased with Brando’s character.  In the novel he never has the epiphany Brando has.  Instead the audience must come to the conclusion about the German national character that Brando instead reveals to us.  But I think that’s the difference between film and novels.  In film we try and reveal change through a character, and that’s what happens in The Young Lions.  What we don’t get, though, is some kind of resolution for Brando.  He learns something but he doesn’t get to have any experiences afterwards - there no real closure.  Maybe that’s another point of the film, though.   People don’t always get a second chance to be good. 

     Also, in Hollywood in the 1950s, perhaps the studios were trying to find a way to deal with collective German guilt over the war and the Holocaust in particular.  Brando's character must suffer a fate that meets the weight the of Germany's crimes.  He's the sacrificial lamb, made even more sympathetic, perhaps, because of his earlier epiphany.

All drawings by J. Betke

Monday, June 2, 2014

Third Coast Comics Promo

Here's a short video I did promoting Chicago's Third Coast Comics.

See more about Third Coast here:

http://thirdcoastcomics.com/

Saturday, April 26, 2014

Three Stars in Films About Class

Jean Arthur, If You Could Only Cook

"If You Could Only Cook" (1935) was a new film for me.  Jean Arthur is out of work; she meets Herbert Marshall while sitting on a park bench going through the want ads.  She mistakes him for someone also looking for a job, but he's really an auto magnate.  She finds an ad looking for a married cook and butler couple, and intrigued, he agrees to pretend to be her husband so she can get the job. 

Jean Arthur, "If You Could Only Cook," 1935.
There's comedy in the fact that he's wealthy, and pretending to be a butler; and the fact the guy they work for is actually a mobster.  As in many of these comedies there are a few cliched complications that would be easily solved if the characters just talked to each other.  When he shows her some of his drawings of experimental cars, she tries to get him a job at a rival auto company, who immediately recognize the drawings and arrest her for theft!  And Marshall also keeps secret his pending marriage to a boring socialite.  Eventually it takes the meddling of the mobster they work for to force them together. 

Ultimately this isn't really a movie about class; there is little commentary on the reasons for Arthur's plight, or how poorly the down and out are treated.  It's interesting, though, that the mobster is accepted as a member of the upper class, despite his criminal background.  Old money, new money, it doesn't really matter in America in the 1930s.  As long as you had it!

Carol Lombard, My Man Godfrey


Carol Lombard "My Man Godfrey," 1936.
I love how Carol Lombard is something of a mess in "My Man Godfrey" (1936) trying to prove herself to her more sophisticated sister.  It's clear she has the bigger heart, but she also has misconceptions about why people suffer and what they need to get out of "Skid Row."  I'm glad she gets reunited with William Powell at the end of the film and she gets to see that "forgotten men" just want to work - they just need the opportunity to do so.

Comparing this role to what she did in films like "To Be or Not To Be" we can see what a great actress she was, especially in comedies.

Katherine Hepburn, The Philadelphia Story

Katherine Hepburn, "The Philadelphia Story," 1940.

I was aiming for Tracy Lord, Goddess in this sketch from "The Philadelphia Story" (1940).  She's so perfect as a representative of the upper class who needs to see that flaws in people aren't a sign of a flawed soul, a common misconception among those who were born to comfort.